MAY 2019
Image may be subject to copyright
Publication date: 2014
WCRG meeting: 15 May 2019
Rating: 5.9
Station Eleven is a post-apocalypse novel in which most of the world was destroyed by a pandemic. “A virulent new strain of flu that "exploded like a neutron bomb over the surface of the earth", wiping out 99% of humanity; characters holed up in tower blocks while the world collapses around them; "unspeakable years" in which the unlucky survivors walk blasted roads in search of vestiges of civilisation; crazed prophets leading murderous cults and "ferals" leaping out from behind bushes.”.
The flu pandemic which was the catalyst for the story was viewed very differently across the group. For some this was felt to be very believable, whereas others felt that this was just a very easy and not very believable plot device and compared this to other dystopian novels, such as Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, which has a much more nuanced and worked out backstory to explain how we arrived at the world in which the book takes place. Other members again agreed that it was clearly a plot device, but still felt the use of the flu pandemic plot was needed and appropriate.
It was pointed out that some kind of dictator/prophet always comes forward in times where structures fall apart.
It was interesting to see the different ways people deal with extreme situations: from believe in something spiritual to people wanting to archive /preserve.
To many the book felt disconnected between the two stories (‘aftermath of the flu pandemic’ and ‘the actor and his three ex-wives’). Many members felt that the links between different people didn’t work, that it was difficult to keep track of characters and especially that some chapters giving background to main characters (for example Arthur) came too late in the book.
What people liked about the book was that it was an interesting and different way to approach the topic. It was not purely a dystopian novel but also covered many other topics, such as what really matters, memory, regret, literature, adult/modern life etc. It also had some good metaphors, e.g. connectedness (through phones/internet, air & sea travel). Some also liked the use of the genre of graphic novel in the book. There was hope running through the book, with towns being established and Shakespeare still being played.
One criticism which repeatedly came up during our discussion was that some things didn’t ring true. It was interesting to see that different readers picked up on different points on this one (electricity, survivors, flu pandemic), and let other points go or were not bothered by it. Many liked the motto of the Travelling Symphony ‘Survival is insufficient’.
Overall, many found the book a bit too simplistic, and thought it needed a lot more work; more than one member of the group said, that it felt like a first book and that the author seemed a bit self-indulgent. However, others just enjoyed the read, and the way it made them think. The group’s average score was 5.9.
MARCH 2019
Image may be subject to copyright
Book: The Shepherd's Life: A Tale of the Lake District, James Rebanks
Publication date: 2015
WCRG meeting: 13 March 2019
Rating:
Publication date: 2015
WCRG meeting: 13 March 2019
Rating:
REVIEW TO FOLLOW
Book: Milkman, Anna Burns
Publication date: 2018
WCRG meeting: 23 January 2019
Rating: 7.3
Thank you to all who meet, or submitted their observations, to our meeting last Wednesday, where we discussed Milkman by Anna Burns.
Even though this is a novel about the Troubles in Northern Ireland and takes fear and division as its subject, the group was able to discuss it amicably. We were lucky to have one member who had lived there and was able to say that from her first-hand knowledge this gives a very good image of the life there.
We began with a discussion of the way the book is written and consequently read. Everyone agreed that the way it is put down on the page makes it difficult at first as the paragraphs are long and not broken up. One of us had listened to it on Audible rather than reading it on the page and had very much enjoyed the discursive, stream of consciousness nature of the telling.
JANUARY 2019
Image may be subject to copyright
Publication date: 2018
WCRG meeting: 23 January 2019
Rating: 7.3
Thank you to all who meet, or submitted their observations, to our meeting last Wednesday, where we discussed Milkman by Anna Burns.
Even though this is a novel about the Troubles in Northern Ireland and takes fear and division as its subject, the group was able to discuss it amicably. We were lucky to have one member who had lived there and was able to say that from her first-hand knowledge this gives a very good image of the life there.
We began with a discussion of the way the book is written and consequently read. Everyone agreed that the way it is put down on the page makes it difficult at first as the paragraphs are long and not broken up. One of us had listened to it on Audible rather than reading it on the page and had very much enjoyed the discursive, stream of consciousness nature of the telling.
We also considered the narrator’s habit of using titles rather than names which had caused some dismay in reviews but which most of us found funny and also sobering as a reminder of the dangers that were always present in the society where a false move could get you shot and betraying a friend or a relative was easily done. The titles were sometimes descriptive as in ‘Maybe Boyfriend’ and sometimes dismissive as in ‘Third Brother in Law’ and yet reminded us of the complexity and inter-relatedness of the society being described.
We went on to discuss the language and the way in which the writer is fascinated by language and invites us to understand something of the sensitivity where there were prescribed and proscribed names that could be given to babies and you could easily indicate that you were from the wrong religion or the relationship and put yourself beyond the Pale. Even though we heard about Nuns and St Teresa of Avila, we were not made to take sides.
The writer takes a subject where great delicacy of touch was needed and manages to stay sufficiently impartial so that no reader will feel alienated. Our Irish colleague said that to her there were enough signs to indicate one religion more than the other but we could still admire the skill with which we were left to see the stories of the individuals especially the narrator or ‘Middle Sister’.
We thought about the description of poisoning and what place it had in the story. Was it just an indication of a mad, sick society or was it about the way in which people damaged each other? It gave a role to the neighbours considering that no-one could go to hospital in case they got involved with the police or were seen as an informer. The neighbours took on a role almost as a Greek chorus foreboding trouble unless their advice was taken.
The question of the ending was raised. One person in particular thought it was weak and that it lowered the success of the whole book. The first sentence does link to the ending and perhaps makes some kind of structural unity, needed more when the subject is totally about disunity and fear.
We were glad to have written input from some absent members of the group. They had the same division of views as the rest of us- hard to read the long paragraphs, there being no names was disorientating but the overall effect was powerful , rewarding and worth the effort.
The general conclusion was that most of us really liked and appreciated this book and the average score was 7.3. One person suggested that if we took the mode instead of the mean it would have been 9.
We went on to discuss the language and the way in which the writer is fascinated by language and invites us to understand something of the sensitivity where there were prescribed and proscribed names that could be given to babies and you could easily indicate that you were from the wrong religion or the relationship and put yourself beyond the Pale. Even though we heard about Nuns and St Teresa of Avila, we were not made to take sides.
The writer takes a subject where great delicacy of touch was needed and manages to stay sufficiently impartial so that no reader will feel alienated. Our Irish colleague said that to her there were enough signs to indicate one religion more than the other but we could still admire the skill with which we were left to see the stories of the individuals especially the narrator or ‘Middle Sister’.
We thought about the description of poisoning and what place it had in the story. Was it just an indication of a mad, sick society or was it about the way in which people damaged each other? It gave a role to the neighbours considering that no-one could go to hospital in case they got involved with the police or were seen as an informer. The neighbours took on a role almost as a Greek chorus foreboding trouble unless their advice was taken.
The question of the ending was raised. One person in particular thought it was weak and that it lowered the success of the whole book. The first sentence does link to the ending and perhaps makes some kind of structural unity, needed more when the subject is totally about disunity and fear.
We were glad to have written input from some absent members of the group. They had the same division of views as the rest of us- hard to read the long paragraphs, there being no names was disorientating but the overall effect was powerful , rewarding and worth the effort.
The general conclusion was that most of us really liked and appreciated this book and the average score was 7.3. One person suggested that if we took the mode instead of the mean it would have been 9.
No comments:
Post a Comment